The Best Homeowners Insurance You Should Know

Best Homeowners Insurance

Find Best Home Owners Insurance? New York City is identified as the city that by no means sleeps and options a number of the costliest real estate within the country. With unpredictable winter weather and its shut proximity to the coast, homeowners insurance is an essential piece of monetary protection for any home-owner within the Big Apple.

The average value of homeowners insurance in New York City is $1,769 per 12 months. This is considerably greater than the New York state common of $1,186 per yr, however decrease than the national average of $1,899 per 12 months.

However, value isn’t the one factor to suppose about when selecting a house insurance company. Not positive what to look for? Policygenius may help you figure out your protection wants and compare quotes from a quantity of high firms in New York City.

Best homeowners insurance corporations in New York City

Of the businesses we evaluated, State Farm has the lowest fee in New York City, with an average cost of $1,284 per 12 months — still larger than the New York state common, but considerably decrease than the citywide common.

Looking at the largest house insurance coverage corporations in New York City by market share, Policygenius analyzed the newest price data from Quadrant Information Services to find out how a lot you possibly can anticipate to pay with each company in 2022. We then looked at 2021 J.D. Power buyer satisfaction scores and in contrast that with the coverage wants of New York City residents to search out the best homeowners insurance in New York City.

Best Homeowners Insurance Allstate

Allstate’s combine of exceptional customer satisfaction scores, personalised coverage options, and numerous low cost alternatives make it some of the well-liked householders insurance coverage firms available on the market.


  • Several coverage add-ons, together with ones for roof surfaces, water backup, green improvements, and mold protection
  • 8+ discounts, together with autopay, bundling, zero claims, and new homebuyer
  • Get as a lot as 25% off your premiums whenever you bundle home and auto insurance
  • Excellent customer support and claims satisfaction ratings
  • File and track claims online or through its cellular app


  • Rates are sometimes excessive in comparison with competitors

Why Allstate tops our best list

Allstate’s blend of personalized protection choices, out there discounts, and glorious customer service rankings from J.D. Power makes it one of the high suppliers in New York City. With its easy-to-use cellular app and on-line presence, Allstate clients can shortly access their coverage to file and observe a declare.

How to get a quote

Online by way of Policygenius or Allstate

Best Homeowners Insurance Satate Farm

Best Home Owners Insurance Satate Farm. There’s a cause State Farm is considered one of the top-rated insurance coverage corporations in the united states — its customer satisfaction rankings are through the roof, it provides a slew of coverage add-ons for full safety, and makes filing claims through its cell app a breeze.


  • Top-tier coverage add-ons, including tools breakdown, water backup, and repair line coverage
  • Get as a lot as $1 million in private legal responsibility coverage
  • Score discounts for bundling, putting in safety gadgets, and choosing a excessive deductible
  • File and observe claims on-line, over the telephone, in particular person, or by way of its cellular app
  • High customer satisfaction and financial strength ratings


  • No discounts for first-time homebuyers or going a yr with no claim

Why State Farm tops our best list

State Farm has an excellent J.D. Power ranking and an excellent common value for Big Apple residents. The insurance giant offers a whole line of coverage options, allowing clients to customise their owners insurance based on their needs.

How to get a quote

Online through State Farm

Best Homeowners Insurance Chubb

Best Home Owners Insurance Chubb is a top-tier insurer best for high-value properties that want more strong protection that goes beyond the run-of-the-mill options offered by conventional insurance coverage companies.


  • Base insurance policies embrace extended alternative value coverage in your home and alternative value coverage in your private property — two perks that price further with most other corporations
  • Helps you discover momentary residing arrangements if your personal home can’t be lived in after a coated loss
  • No deductible on losses higher than $50,000
  • Cash-out declare settlement possibility means you’ll find a way to still get paid even when you decide not to restore your home after a covered loss


  • Rates are amongst highest in the business
  • Will only insure high-value homes

Why Chubb tops our greatest list

Chubb is a good possibility for householders in NYC because it focuses on costly properties that want more protection than lower-priced conventional properties. With base insurance policies that embrace extended replacement cost protection on your residence and private property, Chubb outshines several of its rivals.

How to get a quote

Online through Policygenius or Chubb

Best Homeowners Insurance Travelers

With over one hundred sixty five years of expertise and impeccable financial ratings, Travelers is probably considered one of the most trusted house insurance companies within the business. It provides personalised protection and a slew of policy add-ons to guarantee you have exactly the right safety.


  • 4 customizable coverage packages with a quantity of out there add-ons, like extended substitute value and water backup protection
  • Offers eco-friendly green house protection and discounts
  • Protect costly family heirlooms and home equipment with tools breakdown, guaranteed substitute value, and private articles protection
  • File claims online — plus, Travelers has special catastrophe centers for claims after a pure disaster


  • Below-average customer service and claims satisfaction ratings

Why Travelers tops our greatest list

With over 165 years in business, Travelers is amongst the most trusted names within the insurance coverage business. It offers four customizable insurance coverage protection choices, so customers can choose what works greatest for them. You can file claims online or by calling 800-252-4633 to talk with a consultant.

How to get a quote

Online via Policygenius or Travelers

Best Homeowners Insurance National General

National General presents a comprehensive and refreshingly fashionable number of house insurance coverages, including assured alternative price and green upgrade coverage for Earth-conscious prospects.


  • Guaranteed and extended alternative value coverage obtainable for your home
  • Option to have your own home rebuilt with eco-friendly materials after a lined loss
  • Offers flood insurance coverage via the NFIP
  • 10+ reductions for bundling, dwelling in a gated community, having a college degree, and extra
  • File claims on-line — with 24/7 claims support


  • Higher charges than most competitors

Why National General tops our greatest list

National General is about protecting more than simply your house and personal belongings. It can be one of many few insurance coverage firms that will pay to rebuild your house with eco-friendly materials after a lined loss.

How to get a quote

Online via National General

Cheapest owners insurance companies by ZIP code in New York City

NYCM has the cheapest common residence insurance rates in the 10118 ZIP code (Koreatown) at $394 per year, which is significantly lower than the state common of $1,186 per yr.

The most reasonably priced areas for owners insurance coverage in New York City

The Big Apple is an costly place to reside, so if you’re considering shifting, take a look at one of these neighborhoods which have essentially the most reasonably priced charges in the city. With a mean annual premium of $1,455, the 10302 ZIP code (Staten Island), is essentially the most inexpensive area for house insurance in New York City.

The most costly areas for owners insurance coverage in New York City

With a mean annual premium of $1,880, the 10021 ZIP code (Lenox Hill) is the costliest ZIP code in New York City for residence insurance coverage. But understand that this is solely round $111 greater than the city average of $1,769.

If you live in these neighborhoods, your rates might be among the highest in New York City.

Shopping for owners insurance in New York City

Every home-owner has totally different insurance coverage wants and when shopping for house insurance, you need to ensure that the quote you obtain displays your personal state of affairs. What works for your neighbor won’t necessarily be one of the best resolution for you.

In the sections under, we’ll have a look at the cheapest and costliest home insurance providers in NYC for canine house owners, pool owners, and people with low credit score scores, in addition to average annual rates with completely different protection and deductible ranges. When you’re ready to shop for house insurance coverage, the experts at Policygenius can guide you through the method and find reasonably priced choices in New York that work best for you.

New York City house insurance prices by coverage amounts

Dwelling coverage is the part of your house insurance coverage that may pay to rebuild your personal home from the ground up after a covered loss.

In New York City, the common annual fee for a house with $500,000 in dwelling coverage is $2,866, nearly $1,600 larger than the state average.

Personal legal responsibility coverage protects you and your property against damages if somebody is injured or their property is broken in your property. Basically, if someone falls down or journeys and needs to go to the hospital, legal responsibility protection will usually pay the medical bills of the injured party.

As seen in the table beneath, extra legal responsibility coverage doesn’t necessarily correlate with larger common home insurance coverage premiums in New York City. Opting for prime legal responsibility coverage limits typically has a minimal impact on your total price, making it a great worth add for any policy.

New York City home insurance coverage prices by deductible amount

Your deductible is the quantity you’re responsible for paying on an insurance claim earlier than your insurance coverage kicks in. Although higher deductibles typically imply a lower monthly cost, you pay extra out of pocket on a claim for a coated loss.

As seen in the desk beneath, New York City residents can save round $500 on residence insurance by selecting a $2,000 deductible over the $500 option.

Home insurance reductions in New York City

Home insurance is expensive but there are discounts out there if your own home has certain features like deadbolts or security techniques. The greatest low cost is for those homeowners with a burglar alarm who can count on to avoid wasting almost $100 per yr on their home insurance coverage.

Home insurance companies in New York City for dog owners

Owning a pet, particularly a dog, is a pleasure many households in NYC get pleasure from, but if your dog bites somebody in your property, you could be sued for damages.

In some places, certain breeds deemed as “dangerous” typically see higher insurance coverage premiums from insurance coverage firms. But lawmakers in Illinois, New York, and Nevada are pushing for legislation that bans insurance coverage corporations from discriminating against certain breeds.

With a median rate of $2,489 per 12 months, Chubb has the most costly insurance coverage charges in New York City for a home with a harmful canine breed, whereas State Farm has the lowest charges.

Home insurance companies in New York City for poor credit

A poor credit score not only impacts your probabilities of being permitted for a automobile loan or a mortgage, nevertheless it additionally impacts the charges you’ll pay for insurance. Insurance firms consider those with a low credit score as more likely to file an insurance declare and thus charge larger premiums.

With a mean rate of $1,916 per 12 months, State Farm has the most cost effective home insurance coverage rates for New York City householders with poor credit, whereas Allstate has the most costly rates.

Home insurance firms in New York City for pool owners

If you’re contemplating buying a new home and it has a pool then you’ll likely need to increase the amount of liability coverage on your house. Home insurance corporations consider a pool a liability risk and will charge owners greater premiums.

Here are the average yearly rates for householders in New York City who have a swimming pool. State Farm has the lowest charges at $1,156 per year, while Pure Insurance has the very best rates.

How to purchase owners insurance in New York City

Now that you’ve seen a number of the totally different options and coverages obtainable for home insurance coverage in New York City, here are a couple of steps you can take to seek out the best coverage:

  1. Reach out to a licensed Policygenius agent. Our skilled agents may help you discover quotes from high corporations based mostly on the type of coverage wanted.
  2. Consider buying flood and hurricane insurance. Hurricane Sandy left many householders in the New York area riddled with damaged properties from heavy winds and flooding. Standard home insurance insurance policies don’t cowl floods, so ask your Policygenius agent about your options if you need this sort of safety.
  3. Figure out how a lot you’ll find a way to afford to pay on your deductible. A larger deductible means you’ll pay much less in your yearly owners coverage, so ask your Policygenius agent to discover a deductible that works greatest for you.
  4. Compare quotes from a Policygenius agent. Once you’ve identified your coverage needs, limits, and deductibles, Policygenius brokers will ship over a list of quotes from high corporations and supply suggestions that best suit your needs.
  5. Choose your coverage, sign it, and pay your first premium. Once you’ve determined which plan works finest for you, your Policygenius agent will do all the paperwork for you. All you need to do is sign the paperwork and pay your first premium. It’s that easy!

Frequently requested questions

Why is house insurance coverage so costly in New York City?

Home insurance coverage is so expensive in NYC because the city has a few of the highest-valued properties within the nation. The extra something prices, the more insurance coverage firms will cost to guard it.

How can I lower my householders insurance coverage in New York City?

The best method to decrease the cost of your house insurance coverage is by comparing quotes. Once you’ve settled on a couple of suppliers, make sure to ask about any reductions which may apply to your situation, so you can save even more cash.

Do I really need to purchase more insurance if I even have an aggressive dog?

If you own a dog that is thought of an aggressive breed, you can purchase further safety. A single trip to the ER can cost hundreds of dollars or a possible lawsuit, that means you might be on the hook for thousands of dollars in damages.


Policygenius has analyzed home insurance charges supplied by Quadrant Information Services in March 2022 for ZIP codes in all 50 states plus Washington, D.C., for a 40-year-old female home-owner with no declare historical past, good credit score, a $1,000 deductible, and the next protection limits:

  • Dwelling: $300,000
  • Other structures: $30,000
  • Personal property: $150,000
  • Loss of use: $60,000
  • Liability: $300,000
  • Medical: $1,000

All charges based on the above coverage limits except where otherwise famous.

Some carriers may be represented by affiliates or subsidiaries. Rates provided are a sample of prices. Your actual quotes may differ.

Check Also

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in NY : 4 Choices For You

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in NY : 4 Choices For You

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in NY When shopping for homeowners insurance in New York, there …